Shopping is my nemesis. I’m cheap and prefer used to new, but I like high quality goods that will last long enough to delay the shopping experience a good healthy while. I’ve already dumped more into H’Appy’s current tack set up than I did in total over 10 years with Gem, ugh.
There are a few more pieces I’d like to change out though which means more shopping and spending more money. Before hitting the various online and app based used tack places to search through crappy ads with bad pictures and important information missing , I thought I’d hit up the blogging community. You all are much better tack hoarders than I am and I was hoping to snag some used items from one of you instead of a complete stranger.
The two items I’d really like to snag right now are new irons and a set of iron covers. Seems like I need to do a better job protecting my new precious saddle with its luxe leather. The iron covers are nicely priced on Etsy and I am fine ordering from there, but maybe one of you makes them and wants some side hustle money? I’d buy the Bates ones, but they are purple and I’ve already sunk low enough to use navy. Purple is not going to happen. Seems like once you start down the purple road your brain turns to a purplish mush and you go insane.

Irons are more difficult to figure out. The Bates saddle I took on trial before ordering mine had wonderful stirrups on them. Unfortunately I wasn’t smart enough to take a picture or ask the brand before returning the saddle. I’ve done some research and I believe they were the Compositi wide bed with shock absorber like below:

I’m not set necessarily on that specific brand, but I really liked the wide foot bed, the aggressive tread and the slight give it had. The only two things I wished it had were a 90 degree eye so it laid correctly on the leathers and were a bit heavier than the plastic composition.
They aren’t even that expensive online, but again maybe a blogger has a pair they aren’t using and want some cash with show season around the corner. Anyone have anything similar they want to sell before I buy new?
No help in having you find a pair… but the MDC irons with the springs should check all those boxes for you (rotating head, wide & aggressive tread, more substantial weight, and some give). personally, I hate stirrups with give because I feel like it makes it hard to “ground” myself in my stirrups, but I think its a 100% personal thing. You can probably find a pair online fairly reasonably.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’ve tried the MDC and didn’t like them. These compositi ones don’t have give in the sense that you can feel the stirrup bed moving under the foot. It’s more just a light shock absorption effect. I don’t know. Hard to explain. But thanks for the suggestion!!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Totally disregard me then! I think stirrups are such a personal preference. You have to just ride in as many of them as you can until you find what you like.
LikeLike
I never disregard any suggestion! All are welcome and appreciated 🙂 KC just commented on the MDC as well so maybe I need to re look at those
LikeLiked by 1 person
So because I grew up completely cheap, stretched out,old socks will fit over irons – especially men’s socks.
I bought a set of compositi stirrups and absolutely love them. They’re lighter, float nicely with your footbed, and if you do lose one they’re not a pound of metal hitting the horse. I found mine at Dover on deep discount for around $ 20 bucks. Warning though, I did buy purple ones!😉
LikeLike
That’s a good idea with the socks. I wonder if Dusty would notice?
Thanks for the mini review on the stirrups. I really liked them on that trial saddle. But no purple. What is up with all you purple people? It’s like a cult
LikeLike
LOL! The purple, I believe, is a product of moving and trying a lot of different riding styles. I started out eventing/hunters (SC)and we moved to a really heavy stock horse and saddleseat area(NC)-so I bought an Appy. Then we moved to AZ. Which is a hodgepodge of western/games/dressage/hunters. Then we moved to the black hole of the horse industry (coastal GA). When I got to NoVA-where all things western or games or flashy are derided in the most hardcore fashion-I choose to be cheekily obnoxious. These are like the Compositi ones I got (and it’s a good price, too!):
https://www.statelinetack.com/item/shires-premium-profile-stirrup-treads/E017440%20BLK/?srccode=GPSLT&gclid=Cj0KCQiAj4biBRC-ARIsAA4WaFio_IcAMwtzcmEmIsG17iLzrKUF5wFddLstbydAsSohqnYLZ5rrAHoaAm7pEALw_wcB
LikeLike
I should have looked at that harder, those are just the treads. But that’s the design of the stirrup. Sorry!
LikeLike
I just bought a pair of stirrup covers because my MDC ones were leaving marks on my BRAND NEW Millbrook leathers. I got the below pair in black with turquoise monogram/jumper logo an they look awesome. Because of the size of the MDC (wide base), she needed to custom make a larger size and my total, including shipping/tax, was $21. Highly, highly recommend. They fit great, look great, and do the job.
https://www.etsy.com/listing/609067544/personalized-glitter-jumping-horse
As far as irons, I really like my MDC Super Sports. I don’t have a lot to compare them to, though, since once I buy something and like it, I tend not to go searching for something else. But they have a wide base, are heavy enough that if you lose it, it’s easy to find it (unlike some lightweight stirrups that just go flying around), you can rotate them 3 different ways, and they have the flexible sides which were a lifesaver for me when I broke my ankle. Not sure if those were the ones you tried, as they have a few different models.
LikeLike
I’ll have to try the MDC again. I tried them years ago and wasn’t a fan but I’m sure they have changed.
Thanks for the Etsy heads up. I’ll give them a look and see what they have
LikeLike
another vote for the MDC stirrups. LOVE THEM. (I have bad knees and bad ankles and they help me so much). My feet never (hardly ever) fall out of them even on some doozies of a missed distance HA. I have the Flex ones. LOVE THEM. They are not light but I love the wide tread and they stay where they need to stay. AND WHY NOT PURPLE STIRRUP COVERS?? you are so unimaginative 🙂 HA HA HA
https://www.statelinetack.com/item/mdc-s-flex-stirrups/E014004%2005/?srccode=GPSLT&gclid=Cj0KCQiAj4biBRC-ARIsAA4WaFjfLX8ifOx9rAy6jCDTH1KgwH1WOp1QgK_Z1wHVqU9-ZK5L8FYKuMEaAgk4EALw_wcB
LikeLike
Purple changes people. And not for the better…..LOL!!!
LikeLiked by 1 person
bite your tongue woman 🙂 Embrace the purple :)!
LikeLike
I use the exact stirrups you have a picture of and I love them. I do love that the composite is light and not heavy, and I think that the fact that they’re plastic keeps them from marking my saddle as much as metal. They’re grippy enough for me – I think my feet have come out of those maybe once in the almost 2 years I’ve had them. So I really like these. As for stirrup covers, I made myself a pair of Ravenclaw covers because no else had the fabric/pattern that I was looking for (seriously everyone has either Slytherin or Gryffindor; where are the Ravenclaws and Hufflepuffs?! Plus, the fabric wasn’t fleece). It was a super fun (and super fast) project, so I dunno but if you can’t find anything you like in stirrup covers I’d be more than happy to make you a pair 🙂
LikeLike
All you handy DIY bloggers creating things. I wouldn’t even know where to begin making something. I may take you up on that.
LikeLike
Haha my mom and nana are both wonderful seamstresses, and while I am not I play around a little bit lol. But yeah let me know! They’re easy and fun to make 😊
LikeLike
I think Tracy (printable pony) makes stirrup covers but she is also at WEF right now. You know I never had stirrup covers for my Antares saddle and probably never will and the leather was just fine.
LikeLike
Thank you! I’ll wait and see what she has when she gets back.
LikeLike
We sell patterns for 2 different types of stirrup covers on the printable pony, not the actual covers. I have to say the over the pommel cover pattern, done in fleece, is about the easiest sewing project on the planet . (I am Tracy’s mom and pattern designer)
LikeLiked by 1 person
Oh darn. Even the easiest project is too much for me.
LikeLike
Whaddya mean purple turns the brain to mush?! 😎 what a ridiculous idea.
I have a pair of composite stirrups that I don’t use You could have them but the shipping might be the same as buying new.
At the dollar store you might be able to find some cloth bags that would work.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I think there is scientific proof that purple is an addictive substance that causes temporary insanity when viewed 😉
I wonder how much shipping would cost? Any rough idea?
LikeLiked by 1 person
I think you live in Maryland? If so then it would be (roughly) $25 canadian.
LikeLike
I have those compositi stirrups. I really like them for comfort, but had some safety issues with them. I’d sell you my old pair if I knew where they were. But they’re $30 on RW so you could get them there for super cheap.
LikeLike
What was the safety issue if you don’t mind sharing?
LikeLike
Oh, you’re fine. They’re not super dangerous or anything, but they are not a safety stirrup – there’s nothing to release your foot (rubber band that break, bar the flips out, etc) if you fall off. The issue I actually had with them if they are so light, they flap around, so if you lose your stirrups, you can’t get your foot back in them while still moving. It was one of those bizarre things I had read George Morris bitching about being dangerous years ago and laughed at because GM is always bitching about any new fangled thing being dangerous and ignored until I had a really bad near-fall where I literally could not get my foot back in my stirrup because it was bouncing around in the air. I had to come to a complete stop, let it fall, then put my foot in. I literally remembered that GM rant at that moment and I haven’t ridden in them since. I was thinking I might use them for a trail saddle though – they really are comfortable. The safety issue is minor and if you’re not jumping high/doing XC, I wouldn’t worry about it.
LikeLike
I love my compisiti stirrups too and have had them for roughly 4 years now. Definitely a good price new for their durability.
LikeLike
I am with you as I just do NOT understand purple (sorry to all the purple people eaters out there).
Stirrups-wise I have heard good things about the Free Jumps, MDC, Lorenzini’s and Acavallos.
All come with pretty decent price tags even if you are buying second hand.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’d love to get a pair of Free Jumps but they are out of my price range especially for the level I’m riding.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I have Royal Rider flex stirrups which are what the Compositi are based on I think. They are amazing and super comfortable for me. I think they’re a little heavier than the Compositis, but they’re definitely still a lightweight iron. I want something heavier as we start jumping bigger this year, but I haven’t come up with what I want yet.
LikeLike
Yeah that is my only concern. They feel super light weight and while I don’t often lose a stirrup o like knowing where it will be if I do.
LikeLike
Late to the game – but I can make you stirrup covers if you want. I’ve done a few for other people. I can do any pattern you see on my website, or a plain color, and can add embroidery if you want (monogram, name, farm name, etc.). https://www.etsy.com/shop/BelJoeorMetier
On stirrups – I am low-key in the market for new stirrups and the Compostis were recommended for me by a couple of people. I’ll probably snag a pair whenever I do a supply order next. I thought long and hard about the offset eye but a lot of people were iffy on whether they actually improved hip and knee pain, which was what I would want them for.
LikeLike
Awesome! I’ll order through Etsy tomorrow! I figured someone who read this would be a lot more handy than I am 🙂
LikeLike
Ha, finally got back to checking up on this, sorry! You can either use the “custom order” feature or email me at beljoeor@gmail.com.
LikeLike